How long is too long? After seeing what happened when legislators set mandatory minimum prison sentences, even some supporters now think it's time for a change
Article Abstract:
There is widespread dissatisfaction with mandatory minimum sentences among judges and legislators. The mushrooming war on drugs gave rise to these sentences, which started appearing in federal laws in 1986. Critics charge that they strip judges of discretion, remove compassion from sentencing and compound the problem of prison overcrowding. Critics feel these setences also mandate unduly harsh sentences for minor, nonviolent criminals. Some federal legislators have introduced legislation giving judges a 'safety valve' with some minimum mandatories.
Publication Name: ABA Journal
Subject: Law
ISSN: 0747-0088
Year: 1993
User Contributions:
Comment about this article or add new information about this topic:
The verdict is in; throw out mandatory minimum sentences, judges tell ABA Journal poll
Article Abstract:
The ABA Journal conducted a survey of 401 federal and state judges to elicit their views on mandatory minimum sentences. The poll found 90% of federal judges thinking that mandatory minimum sentences for federal drug offenses were a bad idea. Undue harshness of sentences for first-time offenders was the biggest complaint, while sentences for recidivists drew less criticism. Many judges felt mandatory minimums hit minorities more harshly than whites. Federal judges expressed the most dissatisfaction.
Publication Name: ABA Journal
Subject: Law
ISSN: 0747-0088
Year: 1993
User Contributions:
Comment about this article or add new information about this topic:
Limits on legislators' terms upheld; Calif. court rules initiative does not infringe rights of voters or candidates
Article Abstract:
The California Supreme Court upheld the state's term limit law in a 6-1 decision Oct 10, 1991. Chief Justice Malcolm Lucas held that the public has a right to term limits as protection 'against an entrenched, dynastic legislative bureaucracy.' The court also held that the power to enact term limits should not reside with the state legislature. An appeal by the legislature is expected.
Publication Name: ABA Journal
Subject: Law
ISSN: 0747-0088
Year: 1992
User Contributions:
Comment about this article or add new information about this topic:
- Abstracts: Talking heads speak up; dictating legal matters still has many proponents, even in this high-tech age. Staking out a detective
- Abstracts: New strategy in battering cases: about a third of jurisdictions prosecute even without victim's testimony. Jury deadlocks in Oswald mock trial; verdict based on "testimony" of actor-witnesses elicited by real-life lawyers
- Abstracts: Justices narrow boycott definition in Hartford ruling. Antitrust ruling does not let Microsoft off hook; consent decree decision by D.C. Circuit isn't as bad for U.S. as depicted
- Abstracts: Prepping the CEO: it is important - and hard - to teach some witnesses not to hurt themselves
- Abstracts: Estate may not deduct payment of non-enforceable charitable pledges. No charitable deduction because amount of bequest not determinable