The qualitative dimension of Fourth Amendment "reasonableness"
Article Abstract:
The quantitative procedural approach to protections afforded by the Fourth Amendment should be supplemented by a qualitative substantive approach. The procedurally-based expectation of privacy test unnecessarily limits constitutional protections. Findings of unreasonableness of searches and seizures should include a balancing test opposing an individual's security and privacy interests against the specific class or classes of search and seizure. This consideration of substantive privacy interests is consistent with constitutional precedent.
Publication Name: Columbia Law Review
Subject: Law
ISSN: 0010-1958
Year: 1998
User Contributions:
Comment about this article or add new information about this topic:
Is Morrison v. Olson still good law?: the court's new appointments clause jurisprudence
Article Abstract:
Expansive prosecutions since the Morrison v. Olson ruling, which gave independent counsels rather than members of the executive branch the power to investigate and prosecute officials of that branch, demonstrated the Ethics in Government Act's latent dangers which were not apparent when the statute was enacted. Congress should create an independent office composed of commissioners selected through nomination and confirmation to correct the Appointments Clause infirmity and eliminate many of the causes of the abuse.
Publication Name: Columbia Law Review
Subject: Law
ISSN: 0010-1958
Year: 1998
User Contributions:
Comment about this article or add new information about this topic:
- Abstracts: Innocence, privacy, and targeting in Fourth Amendment jurisprudence. Fourth Amendment in increasing danger
- Abstracts: Lasting stigma: affirmative action and Clarence Thomas's prisoners' rights jurisprudence. Criminal trials - subpoenas - Connecticut adopts a "compelling need" test to limit the ability of prosecutors to subpoena defense attorneys
- Abstracts: Recording your own CD-ROMs. Turning paper into bytes. EZ Drive vs. Zip drive: which is best?
- Abstracts: Ten shopping tricks that will improve your computer (and not deplete your bank account). Remote safety: Windows provides safe, simple remote access