Persistent vegetative state, withdrawal of artificial nutrition and hydration, and the patient's "best interests." (response to article by Andrea Fenwick in this issue, p. 86)(Editorial)
Article Abstract:
A paper which challenges the use of the 'best interests' argument to justify the withdrawal of life-prolonging treatment (LPT) from patients in a persistent vegetative state is evaluated. The paper states that the 'best interests' argument is medically oriented, based on a delusory objective and illogical. However, it is argued that the withdrawal of LPT is ethical since its provision would not benefit the patient and deprive others needing LPT.
Publication Name: Journal of Medical Ethics
Subject: Philosophy and religion
ISSN: 0306-6800
Year: 1998
User Contributions:
Comment about this article or add new information about this topic:
Commentary 3: a response to Lowe
Article Abstract:
The growing practice of turning off respirators as a response to a patient's wish must be given proper attention in the medical profession. Medical law must also be developed and applied to new circumstances. However, changing the law would be a very complicated process since improvements must be done internally. Hence, only a court's decision can determine the developments that can be done in medical law.
Publication Name: Journal of Medical Ethics
Subject: Philosophy and religion
ISSN: 0306-6800
Year: 1997
User Contributions:
Comment about this article or add new information about this topic:
- Abstracts: What can medical ethics learn from history? Commentary 1: the right to refuse treatment. Commentary 2: thesis correct: argument unconvincing
- Abstracts: Environmental risk problems and the language of ethics. A new environmental ethic
- Abstracts: Toward a theory of the ethics of bureaucratic organizations. part 2 Perfecting imperfect duties: collective action to create moral obligations
- Abstracts: Stakeholder management theory: a critical theory perspective. The infelicities of business ethics in the third world: the Melanesian context
- Abstracts: Trust and ethics in employee-owned companies. What have we learned about trust from recent experiences with teaming and empowerment?