Discussion by Thomas L. Theis, member, ASCE

Article Abstract:

An editorial of the future of environmental engineering has been disputed, particularly on the subject of environmental engineering having grown into a distinct and independent engineering discipline. The editorial claims that the broad nature of environmental engineering makes it a potential separate discipline. However, it is this characteristic that creates a doubt as to whether it deserves to be an independent engineering field. It should be noted that other mainline engineering disciplines were established through narrow contexts.

---

Discussion

Article Abstract:

The regulation requiring the installation of backflow prevention devices in fire sprinkler systems could result in additional expenses for the building owner. The Cross Connection Advisory Committee of the Department of Environmental Protection responsible for these regulations is made up of individuals with vital economic interests in monitoring the compliance of backflow regulations. The public and the fire-fighting community are not represented in the group.

Health aspects, Laws, regulations and rules, Fire prevention, Fire sprinklers, Cross-connections (Plumbing), Cross connections (Plumbing)

---

Discussion by Paul A. Kuhn, fellow, ASCE

Article Abstract:

An editorial implying that environmental engineering has matured into a separate engineering discipline has been disputed. Environmental engineering remains as a branch of civil engineering that addresses related fields such as mechanics, themodynamics, materials as well as basic and applied sciences and mathematics. Environmental engineering can continue its growth under the guidance of the American Society of Civil Engineers.

Management, Forecasts and trends, Civil engineering, American Society of Civil Engineers

Similar abstracts:

• Abstracts: Beyond Earth Day. The East Austin solution. Curbing recycling revisionists: refuting a bevy of critics, recycling advocates say curbside recycling makes economic sense
• Abstracts: Stachys germanica L. Do species assemblages ever recur?
• Abstracts: Fire in the mother lung. The Duce Syndrome. The role of rural development in protecting tropical rainforests: evidence from Sri Lanka
• Abstracts: Hazardous Waste Law weakened. The sustainability of recycling
• Abstracts: Community modification by a grass invader has differing impacts for marine habits. Topological properties of food webs: from real data to community assembly models

This website is not affiliated with document authors or copyright owners. This page is provided for informational purposes only. Unintentional errors are possible.